Cell Phone Price Controls: The FCC’s Next Power Grab
by Seton MotleyWe’ve already seen the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in illegal and extraordinary fashion commandeer control of the Internet – so as to then impose the ridiculous notion that is Network Neutrality.
Which remains a solution running around looking for a problem – government rushing to drastically increase government to allegedly address a non-existent “crisis.” (Even the fake ones are never allowed to go to waste.)
In addition to being a horrendous overreach of the FCC’s non-existent statutory authority, it is an incredible and unwieldy disruption of the free market.
A free market which has thus far worked amazingly well – as the government-free Web has rapidly developed into the free speech, commerce-rich Xanadu we all know and love. (Internet business now represents 1/6th of the U.S.’s entire economy – an equal share to that of health care.)
The Internet – free from stifling and sloth-inducing regulation – is reinvented for the better again and again, on an almost moment-to-moment basis.
The government, meanwhile, cannot successfully deliver snail mail. It therefore cannot hope to keep up with the mercurial, improvisational Internet – nor should it try.
But Net Neutrality is not just the oppressive burden of ham-handed regulation of the inter-network – it is also a backdoor, stealth imposition of price controls.
Which never work at controlling prices (just ask anyone from the Richard Nixon Administration). They will instead create caps on Internet investment.
Who will want to invest the big-time coin necessary to continue to grow the Web if said investors are mandated by the government to charge less in the aggregate than what they’re in the aggregate investing?
Scarcity – and then government-controlled Web rationing – will be the inevitable result.
And price controls are just what the Media Marxists – for whom and by whom the FCC’s Net Neutrality order was written – want. As demonstrated by the absurd complaints they’ve already filed.
The ultimate objective? To demand via federal fiat that wired and wireless Internet Service Providers (ISPs) do said providing – for free.
After all, as former Obama Administration Internet Czar Susan Crawford insists: “The Worldwide Web belongs to everyone.”
Those who pay for it – and those who don’t.
It’s as if these Leftists are saying “Thanks for the trillion dollar Internet investment – now, fork it over.”
As President Barack Obama promised – spreading that wealth around.
Which brings us to cell phone data roaming. Which is basically this:
Cell Phone Provider A does not have a network in a certain area. Cell Phone Provider B does. So A & B reach an agreement where A pays B to use B’s network in that area.
The reason B has coverage there is because they spent the big-time coin necessary to build their network there. A’s ability to contract with B to use B’s network saves A the big-time coin investment necessary to build their network there.
It’s like renting versus buying an apartment or house. Those who can’t afford to buy rent from those who can.
This data sharing happens ALL the time, and has since cell phones first roamed the Earth.
Not anymore, say the Media Marxists – and the FCC again doing their bidding.
So as to execute yet another regulatory assault on the free market, these Leftists have created yet another non-crisis “crisis” – “bill shock.”
Translation: Someone somewhere is actually having to pay for the cellular service they are using.
“Bill shock” is – like Net Neutrality – just another ruse. A fake “problem” whose big government “solution” allows these Marxist hacks to again batter the private sector and spread the wealth around.
And – like with Net Neutrality – to begin the inexorable slide to the imposition of price controls. With all the attending scarcity and government-enforced rationing to follow.
And – like with Net Neutrality – their ultimate objective is to demand via federal fiat that cellular providers do said providing – for free.
As Ms. Crawford would say, the cellular networks belong to everyone – those who pay for them and those who don’t.
And on Thursday the FCC is poised to again do as the Media Marxists demand – they will at their monthly meeting vote on whether or not to start the “bill shock” rule-making process.
Which – just like with Net Neutrality – they have exactly ZERO authority to do.
But the 3-2 Democrat majority hasn’t yet let that stop them, so….
This latest FCC power grab is not yet an inevitability – the rule-making process is made up of several steps, of which this is only the first. But it appears the Commission is energetically headed that way.
Towards yet another Marxist mess for We the People to clean up.
But thankfully, this is one we can still prevent.
So please, let us do so – before we all have to grab yet another mop.







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
17 Comments
If the FCC insists on childishly playing in the street, then they should expect to get run over by congress.
"The government, meanwhile, cannot successfully deliver snail mail. It therefore cannot hope to keep up with the mercurial, improvisational Internet – nor should it try."
Delivering snail mail to every single solitary address in the country is NOT a trivial activity. It would NOT be profitable for private enterprise to try to duplicate this activity. It's not particularly profitable to deliver mail to the boondocks. Private enterprise would simply ignore the outlying addresses. The government cannot.
Stating that the government doesn't perform a very difficult task as efficiently as desired, doesn't necessarily mean that they can't perform other tasks well. This is truly an Apples to Oranges comparison. It's the author just taking a cheap shot. Not that I want the government involved in something the private industry can perform just as well or better. I just don't believe the opposite is always true.
A gov't designed cell phone would have a 16 foot long antenna, require 6 car batteries, and weight at least 30 pounds (not including the antenna and batteries). And it would never work on weekends, holidays, or any other day that the unions take off.
Oh, and every call would cost $37 and would drop after 73 seconds. Every time.
The FCC (Federal Censorship Commission) MUST be defunded and shut down, and the marxist hacks tossed out on their asses. Sadly, none of our congress critters have the balls to do it.
Couldn't pour pi$$ out of a boot if the directions were written on the heel.
It would NOT be profitable for private enterprise to try to duplicate this activity
You'd be surprised how much delivery has been farmed out by the US post office to private contractors. Last I heard all over night mail was done by contract with vendors.
Oh those poor children. They haven't a clue. Talk about child abuse.
FCC must die…staff prosecuted for treason…treason's reward suggested…
NEVER FORGET the key tenet of lunatic-left d-crat socialist extremism: If it exists, it MUST be taxed, regulated, controlled and totally and completely subject to the will and whim of BIG GOVERNMENT bureaucrats.
Kind of hard to conceal a 16 foot antenna… Guess you will also need an eco-friendly tent, too.
Gee, first they want to control the internet.
Now the cell phones.
Of course they'd still like to have the Fairness Doctrine as well.
Hmm, they seem to want to control all forms of communication and information.
Now why would they want to do that?
Off topic: Bernie Sanders' War on Chinese Bobbleheads! From: ReasonTV | Apr 6, 2011 In the midst of a massive fiscal crisis, a take-no-prisoners budget battle, a historically long recession, and two (make that three) wars, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) knows what really matters. He's pushing the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, D.C. to only sell bobble-heads, T-shirts, snow-globes, and other souvenirs that are made in America. After getting a letter from and taking a meeting with the self-described Green Mountain State socialist, the folks at the Smithsonian have agreed to increase the amount of domestically produced junk for sale in their gift shops. They're even constructing a new gift shop solely to products manufactured in America that will be called the Price of Freedom.
http://www.youtube.com/user/ReasonTV
"A genuine leader is not a searcher for consensus but a molder of consensus."Martin Luther King, Jr.
government rushing to drastically increase government to allegedly address a non-existent “crisis.”
The very essence of progressivism.
….and
Satellite Usage Fees
Airwave Tax
Bandwidth Analysis Tax
Environmental Impact Fees
Licensing Tax
CO2 Expulsion (Talking)Tax
Battery Disposal Tax (x number of car batteries required)
Automotive Usage Fees
Electronics Certification Fees
Free Speech Tax
and the excessive tax Tax
There is a free app that you can download off any of the app stores like itunes, blackberry app world, android market for your smartphone or tablet – called TELICOST-LITE. and its free. its great. it prevents you from going over your plan limits. it tracks your usage in REAL-TIME, how cool is that? http://www.telicost.com
Democrats are the REAL neo-nazis. They are all about control and eliminating Free Speech (unless you agree with them). The idea that the Federal government is the driver of the U.S. economy, or is the ideal of efficiency, is so ludicrous that only seriously troubled people believe it. (M. Savage- "Liberalism is a Mental Disorder") I think the Socialist/Marxist-controlled Democratic Party is going to be EXTINCT after 2012, a la the Whig or Bull Moose parties……
You must be logged in to post a comment.